Apologetics… and the Movies

pacific01Recently, my teenage son and I settled down to watch the miniseries The Pacific. It’s a gripping production of war in the Pacific in World War 2, following the lives of several young Marines. We’re both history buffs, and with the magic of Hollywood, it was not difficult to imagine that we were viewing the actual events.

We talked about what life would be like for those young fighters. But what really got my attention was a scene in which one Marine is holding a Bible and the other, seeing him, asks with a sarcastic smile whether he is a believer. I always tune in to these TV portrayals of apologetics and this one turned out to be a good opportunity to examine a type of challenge that many Christian apologists will face.

The scene unfolds with the questioner asking the other Marine to confirm that God created everything, including the Japanese soldiers that are trying to kill him. The believer’s response – "free will, what we choose to do" – wasn’t bad. But since he’s God, the questioner persists, he knows what we are going to do before we do it. "Predestination" is the believer’s unexplained response. The questioner then springs the apparent trap: “So the whole game is fixed while we’re down here, for what, his entertainment? That makes us chumps or God’s a sadist and either way I got no use for him."

No answer to this challenge is offered. Instead, a question is asked: “So, what do you believe in?” The questioner answers quickly: “ammunition.” This of course draws a laugh. He ends with the request that the other Marine ask God to sink a few transports so he can get out of there and go home.

Great dialogue, from a theatrical standpoint, but it left the issue hanging unresolved. I was debating whether to weigh in when I saw my son looking over at me with a growing smirk. "Well?" was all he said. When he paused the video, I knew he wanted – needed – an answer…


PleaseConvinceMe Blog: Apologetics… and the Movies

The Poached Egg

Worth Watching: The Pacific (HBO Miniseries) | Band of Brothers | The War – A Film By Ken Burns | War Letters