Gravity: The Theory of Intelligent Falling
by Max Andrews
I’ve heard gravity used as an example as a means of mocking intelligent design by its equivocation to Darwinism. I’ve dialogued with Darwinists and when I refer to their position on evolution as Darwinism some have retorted with, “I believe in gravity, does that make me a Newtonian?” There are so many fallacious equivocations with comparing Darwinism to gravity that it’s a bit embarrassing for the mocker to make such a claim. What spurned this post was question asked by a skeptic at the Glasgow Skeptics at the Pub talk with the University of Minnesota Biology Professor PZ Myers. After a question by Jonathan McLatchie, an intelligent design proponent, Dr. Myers proceeded to ridicule McLatchie (I’ll comment on this in another post, you can read more on Dr. Myers’ reaction here). The following question was asked by a skeptic right after McLatchie’s debacle with Dr. Myers.
Why do you think evolutionary biology is such a target for creationists? I mean, if you had been talking about general relativity you wouldn’t expect people to be here advocating intelligent falling [inaudible… “spaghetti monster”]. So why do you think it is that evolutionary biology is such a target?
Dr. Myers proceeded to answer the question by stating that physics and cosmology has been criticized by creationists. This is true, many creationists (despite the categorical breadth of the term), do challenge the standard model of particle physics and big bang cosmology (among many other models). Dr. Myers was correct in that but he failed to note the equivocation in the question and in his own response. The equivocation is categorical, attempting to compare the strength of explanatory power and scope of Darwinism with gravity. General relativity is, perhaps, the most well established scientific theory that sufficiently explains the relationship between two massive bodies. Darwinism is the theory that all living things descended from an original common ancestor through natural selection and random variation, without the aid of intelligence or nonmaterial forces. Here are my main contentions…
FOLLOW THE LINK BELOW TO CONTINUE READING >>>