The Argumentum ad Smarterum

by Tom Gilson

I’m a firm believer in speaking the truth with love (Eph. 4:15) and letting my speech be gracious, “seasoned with salt” (Col. 4:6). Usually this means practicing great patience and gentleness. There is one frequent form of skeptic/atheist argument, though, for which love demands a firm and intense rebuttal. I’m referring to the argumentum ad smarterum, defined as, if you were smart like me you’d be an atheist (skeptic) like me.

The argumentum ad smarterum usually comes in the form, “Christians are irrational; atheists (or skeptics) are rational.” It also shows up in hand-waving dismissals like “Faith is belief without evidence,” or “You might just as well believe in the Flying Spaghetti Monster.” Sometimes atheists trot out statistics showing that belief in Christianity correlates negatively with educational level.

The argumentum ad smarterum is not to be confused with smart arguments. Well-reasoned arguments based on solid, relevant evidence deserve thoughtful, respectful responses. But the argumentum ad smarterum deserves a smart kick on the backside, especially when it shows up the way I see it so often here. Erstwhile Thinking Christian commenter doctor(logic) adopted the argumentum ad smarterum into his very nom de blog. The not-too-subtle implication was that he was the logical one; but the fact is that quite frequently he wasn’t. (He is still most welcome to comment here, though we have not seen him in a while.)

Sam Harris played a similar tactic, just slightly removed from doctor(logic)’s: he named his organization (not himself, thankfully) Project Reason. When faced with logical arguments, though, he retreated to emotional answers. That was odd, I thought. \

You know plenty more examples, so I need not multiply them for you. Dawkins comes to mind, but in the words of a friend of mine, when I made some remark that opened me up for an obvious wisecrack in response: “Nah, too easy.”

The trap that theists can fall into with the argumentum ad smarterum is to think that it’s about refuting the smarterum arguments (“There’s no more evidence for God than there is for a Flying Teapot!” etc.). That has never worked, in my experience. It’s not following Christ’s example, either. The person who comes presenting this argument comes with a great deal of personal pride; and when Christ saw pride, as in the scribes and Pharisees, he hit it square on. When they laid theological traps for him, he turned around and dealt with their pride instead…


The Argumentum ad Smarterum – Thinking Christian

The Poached Egg Apologetics


Tactics: A Game Plan for Discussing Your Christian Convictions

TacticsIn a world increasingly indifferent to Christian truth, followers of Christ need to be equipped to communicate with those who do not speak their language or accept their source of authority. Gregory Koukl demonstrates how to get in the driver’s seat, keeping any conversation moving with thoughtful, artful diplomacy. You’ll learn how to maneuver comfortably and graciously through the minefields, stop challengers in their tracks, turn the tables and—most importantly—get people thinking about Jesus. Soon, your conversations will look more like diplomacy than D-Day. Drawing on extensive experience defending Christianity in the public square, Koukl shows you how to: – Initiate conversations effortlessly – Present the truth clearly, cleverly, and persuasively – Graciously and effectively expose faulty thinking – Skillfully manage the details of dialogue – Maintain an engaging, disarming style even under attack Tactics provides the game plan for communicating the compelling truth about Christianity with confidence and grace.

List Price: $14.99   Our Price: $10.19   CLICK HERE TO ORDER NOW >>>

The Apologetics of Jesus

TheApologetics of Jesus

How did Jesus defend the faith? The Apologetics of Jesus presents the Savior at his convincing best. The most tentative Christian–or belligerent skeptic–will find meaty arguments for the godhead of Christ through his parables, prophecies, and more. This hard-hitting resource shows how Christ led the curious to commitment. In this original book, readers will find a new way of looking at the message and miracles of Christ and will be revived by the example of Christ’s caring approach to dealing with doubters. Jesus was the ultimate defender of the faith. Learn from his example how to give a valid defense of your beliefs. Recommended for both laypeople and ministry leaders alike!

List Price: $16.99   Our Price: $12.40   CLICK HERE TO ORDER NOW >>>