How to Argue and Disagree Amicably

by Max Andrews

arguing betterThis is an inevitable aspect of life: people will always disagree with you.  What’s very important is how we ought to respond to someone when we disagree.  Here are few points I’d like to share from experience:

Don’t get angry. We love to use ad hominem attacks but remember you’re discussing an argument or position, not the person.  Getting upset is a natural reaction.  When you let your upset disrupt the friendly atmosphere or affect your arguments, STOP.

Stick to the arguments (following 1). Be reasonable and calm.

Go to the person with him you disagree with first.  This is simply Matthew 18.  Don’t write open letters with defamatory comments and unnecessary attacks (a la Norman Geisler).

Do your best to really have a robust understanding of the other position.  You often heard that you should know the other position just as well as you know yours if you want to criticize it. Well, that’s not true and it’s completely infeasible.  It surely helps but here why that phrase is a problem.  To offer criticisms you just need to contrast it with what you believe to be true.  This is simply conversion, contrapositions, obversions, contraries, and contradictions put into play. If you can do that then you don’t need exhaustive knowledge.  If that phrase is true then everyone will be shutting their mouths all day long.

Let the other person speak and don’t interrupt.

Don’t respond if you’ve been emotionally compromised.  Respond when you’re thinking clearly and calm.

It’s okay to be passionately against something but remember, it’s the argument and not the person.  A lot of people take the word ‘ignorant’ and claim you’re using an ad hom. Well, it depends on how you’re using it.  If you say that someone simply lacks knowledge of something then that person is ignorant.  I prefer to say ‘lacks knowledge’ because it’s received better.  So, if you can avoid controversial language that may be apprehended in a distorted way do what you can to avoid it.


How to Argue and Disagree Amicably | Sententtias



Tactics: A Game Plan for Discussing Your Christian Convictions

The Poached Egg Apologetics


Shop at Amazon and help support The Poached Egg!