Too much C.S. Lewis?

By Joel J. Miller

A writer for Relevant magazine is peeved that people like C.S. Lewis. Seriously. “I’m annoyed,” he said, “with the public perception and exultation that has long outlasted him.”

While granting that Lewis deserves credit for his academic, literary, and theological work, the writer pointed out that the Oxford don “was born in 1898 . . . a decade after the setting of Back to the Future III. Annie Oakley was still the most popular woman in America. In 1898, the ink was hardly dry on the patent for the radio and the Wright Brothers had never been to Kitty Hawk.”

But now “[i]t is 2013.” And, well, that just changes everything, right?

The argument hangs on the assumption that Lewis is a product of his times and has trouble speaking to our postmodern world. But the fact that Lewis is a product of his time is exactly why we should still read him. As Lewis himself argued, every age has its own unique outlook. While dead authors are just as likely to go wrong as we are, he said, they’re not likely to go wrong in the same direction, which means their perspectives can serve as a check on, and a corrective to, our own.

‘Like’ The Poached Egg on Facebook!

Books by authors like Lewis (and of course those much older, too) ensure the kind of intellectual diversity that keeps us from getting trapped in our own heads, prisoners to presuppositions we cannot critique for lack of the distance inherent to someone born in the nineteenth, twelfth, or fourth century.

Relevant’s essayist gave a weak nod to this point before landing a stiff jab on the cheek of a straw man. “Our lives can, and should, be informed by Lewis’ writings,” he said. “Future generations can, and should, read what he and others like him wrote. But to use him as the sole foundation for our cultural criticism is a shaky prospect.”

Okay, but this is specious. I don’t know anyone that uses Lewis as the sole foundation for anything. People likely to read Lewis are also likely to read many other and many different authors. But the impression given in the piece is that someone using Lewis is stranded alone on an island named Jack…


The Poached Egg ApologeticsToo much C.S. Lewis?



The Complete C.S. Lewis Signature Classics

Mere Christianity


Shop-at-Amazon-and-help-support-The-[1]Shop at Amazon and help support The Poached Egg!