If These Reasons Wouldn’t Justify Killing a Kitten, Why Would They Justify Abortion?

by J Warner Wallace

For most of my life, I have been unabashedly and unflinchingly pro-choice. For many years, I saw abortion as little more than another form of birth control. Today, I am pro-life. What changed my mind? It wasn’t my conversion to Christianity. My position changed when I started to think carefully about the nature of fetal humans. Once I established the humanity of the unborn (from nothing more than the science), I realized their lives warranted the same protection we offer others in our society. I am, after all, a homicide detective. I investigate killings to determine whether or not they were properly justified. Over the years, I’ve listened to many murder suspects attempt to defend their actions. Here in California, there are only two forms of justified homicide (self-defense and the protection of innocents). Any other form of killing is a murder.

So I was particularly interested to read a recent blog (posted on a parenting site) from a pro-choice advocate who cleverly attempted to use photographs of cats to illustrate “10 Reasons to Have An Abortion”.  In some ways, the post is so outlandish I suspect it must be a mockery, but it does represent common justifications offered for abortion (although, for some reason, the author can only muster 9 defenses). Here is her list, each illustrated with a photograph of a cat or kitten:

1. Having A Baby Would Endanger Your Life
Or cause you medical hardship.

2. Your Birth Control Failed
For whatever reason, your birth control failed. It happens.

3. You Don’t Want To Have A Child Because Of Your Career
You feel like having a baby, taking maternity leave, and caring for a child would harm your career opportunities.

‘Like’ The Poached Egg on Facebook!
Join our Support Team!

4. You Feel You Are Too Young
Maybe you’re a teen with an unplanned pregnancy, or maybe you are any age with an unplanned pregnancy, and you feel you are too young.

5. You Feel You Are Too Old
Maybe your kids have all grown up and left home and you feel you are too old to have a baby. Maybe you feel like your diaper changing days are done.

6. You Feel Strongly About Overpopulation
And you don’t want to add another human to the world.

7. You Are Worried About The Health Of The Baby
Either because of impending miscarriage, Trisomy 13 or Potter’s Syndrome, birth defects or diseases passed down in a family.

8. You Want No Relationship With The Person Who Got You Pregnant
This can be anything from cases of rape and incest, to having a partner with drug or alcohol issues, to domestic violence in a relationship to getting pregnant with someone during a one-night stand.

9. You Don’t Want To Have A Child
For whatever reason. 

You’ve probably heard these kinds of reasons offered to justify abortion in the past. In fact, they mirror the defenses given nationally by women who have had abortions. Take a second look at the list, this time substituting a two year old toddler for the fetal human…

The Poached Egg Apologetics: If These Reasons Wouldn’t Justify Killing a Kitten, Why Would They Justify Abortion?FOLLOW THE LINK BELOW TO CONTINUE READING >>>

If These Reasons Wouldn’t Justify Killing a Kitten, Why Would They Justify Abortion? | Cold Case Christianity


Ratio Christi’s The Poached Egg Apologetics and Christian Worldview Network is a nonprofit ministry in need of your financial
and prayerful support to keep us going and growing. Please join our support team with
an ongoing monthly or a special gift here.