Three Pitfalls for the Christian Apologist to Avoid

by Thomas Rauchenstein

I believe that the task of apologetics is a vital part of the life of the Christian church and its mission in the world. If Christian faith means trusting in Christ on the basis of good grounds or evidence, then the apologetic task of articulating and presenting these grounds to believers, seekers, and skeptics will be an ongoing duty. However, during my course of studying philosophy and theology for the past 20 years, I’ve noticed three pitfalls into which apologists (myself included) tend to blunder – pitfalls that, when left unchecked, undermine the church’s credibility in the marketplace of ideas. Fortunately, we can avoid those blunders by adopting some epistemic humility. Here they are:

1. Reluctance to critique our own beliefs responsibly. It’s an all-too-human tendency to protect our own beliefs by applying more stringent standards to the views we disagree with, and apologists are no exception. To be responsible truth seekers, we need to be consistent in the

CLICK HERE for Amazon Kindle deals in Christian Apologetics: Over 100 titles from 99 cents to $5.99!

application of our critical standards, since if we don’t, we open ourselves to the legitimate charge of hypocrisy. What’s worse, if we fail to engage in equitable self-critique, we run the risk of leading others astray by reinforcing our own status quo. In this context, humility demands that we acknowledge and pay attention to the tension points in our own views, not just the views of others.

2. Reluctance to acknowledge the strong points in others’ views. This point is similar to the first, but it gets to the heart of “loving our neighbour”. Apologists (myself included) can be adept at exposing flaws in other viewpoints, but half-hearted about affirming the cogent aspects of those views. Part of being charitable toward our neighbours is being charitable in how we interpret them! This includes the assumption that we have things to learn from them, instead of waiting to pounce of their very next word…


Three Pitfalls for the Christian Apologist to Avoid | Hope Beyond Reason