Even Christians Can’t Choose Their Own Facts

by Logan Judy

When arguing apologetics, a Christian’s responsibility isn’t to “win.” You wouldn’t know that from scanning through forums and Facebook debates, but it’s true. In fact, to enter into an apologetics discussion or an otherwise spiritual discussion with the intention of “winning,” can be detrimental, because it tempts us to skew the facts in order to prove that we’re right. But winning an argument with dishonest facts doesn’t make us right; far from it.

Think that doesn’t happen with Christians? Think again. This is nowhere worse than it is in the realm of quotes. In a quest to show the legitimacy of Theism and the absurdity (or, to put it more softly, comparative improbability) of Atheism, many go to the Internet for research. There’s nothing wrong with that. But sometimes we pull quotes without looking up the citations to see if they’re accurate and truthful, and the consequences of that can be disastrous.

CLICK HERE for Amazon Kindle deals in Christian Apologetics: Over 100 titles from 99 cents to $5.99!

Take, for example, this quote attributed to Dr. George Wald, a Nobel Prize winner and professor emeritus of biology at Harvard University: ““I do not want to believe in God. Therefore I choose to believe in that which I know is scientifically impossible, spontaneous generation arising to evolution.”

It sounds pretty good, if we want to talk about how even evolutionists are not free of bias. The problem, however, is that Wald never said anything of the sort. The quote was supposedly from a Scientific American interview, but as Dr. Jay L. Wile notes, Wald only appears in one Scientific American article mentioning spontaneous generation, and the phrase “I do not want to believe in God” is found nowhere.

Here’s another popular quote that gets thrown around, this one from Aldous Huxley, author of Brave New World and grandson of “Darwin’s Bulldog”: “For myself, the philosophy of meaninglessness was essentially an instrument of liberation, sexual and political.”

Again, that sounds great. It’s exactly the motivation that some Christians would like for all atheists to admit. If that were true, it would make arguing for our cause a lot easier. But ad hominems seldom contain truth, and in this case, it’s simply taken out of context…


Even Christians Can’t Choose Their Own Facts | A Clear Lens